Potential Impact of the 2024 UK Budget on Small and Medium Enterprises: Rising Costs and Retail Uncertainty

Read Time:7 Minute, 35 Second

As the UK government unveils the 2024 budget under Rachel Reeves, small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) face a unique set of challenges and uncertainties. With changes such as the increase in the National Minimum Wage (NMW) and National Living Wage (NLW), along with stagnant retail sales and renewed calls for business rate reforms, SMEs are bracing for both immediate and longer-term impacts on their operations and profitability. A deeper look into the responses from the Confederation of British Industry (CBI) and recent retail data offers a window into the pressures that SMEs might face in the wake of these fiscal changes.

1. Wage Increases: Impact on Operating Costs and Profit Margins

The 2024 budget includes a significant rise in both the NMW and NLW, measures aimed at improving income equality and protecting the living standards of the lowest earners. While these wage adjustments serve to support fair pay, they also place considerable strain on SMEs that are already operating within tight margins. For many SMEs, especially those in labor-intensive sectors like retail, hospitality, and service industries, increased wage requirements could exacerbate financial challenges.

Business Concerns over Wage Pressures

The CBI’s Chief Policy and Campaigns Officer, John Foster, emphasized that wage hikes, though beneficial for workers, come at a challenging time for SMEs. With productivity levels stagnant, many firms face a dilemma: they must shoulder increased wage expenses while dealing with sluggish growth. Foster warned that without accompanying productivity gains, businesses may struggle to balance higher wages with the investment needed to innovate and grow. For SMEs, whose resources are limited compared to larger firms, rising labor costs can lead to a reduction in hiring, limited wage growth in the future, or even downsizing.

Long-Term Impact on Competitiveness

Increasing wages without a corresponding boost in productivity could have a long-term impact on SMEs’ ability to compete, both domestically and internationally. Businesses may find it increasingly difficult to set aside the funds needed to invest in digital tools, staff training, and product development—all essential for maintaining competitiveness. If SMEs cannot adapt to these changes, they risk falling behind in an economy that is increasingly shaped by innovation and efficiency.

2. Stagnant Retail Sales and Consumer Caution Amid Budget Uncertainty

The economic climate in the months leading up to the budget has added further strain on SMEs. The latest CBI Distributive Trades Survey revealed a dip in retail sales volumes in October, reflecting increased consumer caution and a reluctance to spend due to budget uncertainties. According to the survey, retail sales volumes fell at a modest pace, and seasonal sales expectations are similarly weak, with consumer spending likely to remain cautious through November.

Implications for Retail SMEs

For SMEs in the retail sector, which relies heavily on consistent consumer demand, declining sales volumes add an additional layer of risk. As consumer confidence wanes, SMEs may struggle to maintain cash flow and meet operational costs. Martin Sartorius, Principal Economist at the CBI, attributed part of this cautious spending to the anticipation of budget measures that could impact household finances, suggesting that both consumers and businesses are holding off on spending until they gain more clarity on the new fiscal policies.

Increased Inventory and Demand Uncertainty

The survey also indicated that retail stock volumes remained elevated in October, suggesting that businesses may have overestimated demand and are now dealing with excess inventory. Managing high inventory levels comes with added costs, from storage to stock management, and these burdens can disproportionately impact smaller retailers. The lack of clear demand trends could make it challenging for SMEs to plan ahead, impacting their ability to manage inventory efficiently and anticipate market needs.

3. Call for Business Rate Reforms: Easing the Burden on SMEs

One of the most pressing concerns raised by the CBI is the need for comprehensive reform of the business rates system. Business rates are a significant financial obligation for many SMEs, especially those with physical retail spaces. The CBI has advocated for a “bridging solution” beyond April 2025, when temporary business rate reliefs are set to expire, and proposed a freeze on both the standard and small-business rate multipliers to provide immediate financial relief.

The Impact of Business Rates on SMEs

Without further relief, SMEs could face a steep increase in their financial obligations in 2025, compounding the pressure from rising wages and sluggish retail sales. Business rates are calculated based on property values rather than turnover or profitability, creating a disproportionate burden on businesses with physical storefronts, such as independent shops and high street retailers. For smaller enterprises already struggling with low footfall, rising rates could prove unsustainable, forcing some to shut down or relocate to less desirable areas with lower property values.

Potential for Reform in the Budget

The CBI suggests that the budget could also include measures to hold VAT, corporation tax, and National Insurance contributions at their current levels to provide businesses with some financial predictability. This stability would allow SMEs to make more confident financial projections and investment decisions, though permanent reform of the business rate system remains a priority for many in the sector. If no long-term solutions are proposed, the uncertainty surrounding rates could continue to hinder SME growth and investment.

4. Challenges for Wholesale and Motor Trade SMEs

The impact of budget uncertainties is not limited to the retail sector; the CBI survey also highlighted difficulties in wholesale and motor trades. These sectors reported moderate declines in annual sales volumes, with further declines expected in November. Such trends reflect broader challenges within the distribution sector, with reduced consumer and business spending affecting demand across the supply chain.

Decreased Orders and Supplier Relations

Wholesale SMEs reported a dip in orders placed on suppliers, a trend likely influenced by retailers’ cautious approach in light of reduced sales and uncertain demand. As wholesalers reduce orders, suppliers across the supply chain may feel the knock-on effects, experiencing decreased revenue and higher inventory costs. For SMEs operating within this network, maintaining strong supplier relationships while balancing inventory against demand will be crucial for staying afloat during this uncertain period.

Motor Trades Under Pressure

Motor trade SMEs, which saw a slower pace of decline compared to previous months, still expect ongoing challenges in November. This sector is highly sensitive to economic fluctuations, as consumers often delay significant purchases, such as vehicles, during periods of uncertainty. For smaller car dealerships and motor repair businesses, declining sales volumes could result in cash flow constraints, leading to potential difficulties in covering fixed costs or maintaining adequate staff levels.

5. Balancing Wage Growth and Investment in Productivity

The CBI’s John Foster underscored the importance of a productivity-focused approach to achieve sustainable wage growth across the economy. However, SMEs find themselves caught in a challenging position. With wage growth outpacing productivity, many SMEs are left with limited financial “headroom” to invest in the technologies and training that could improve productivity and, ultimately, support higher wages sustainably.

Risks of Underinvestment in Technology and Innovation

For SMEs, the pressure to meet rising wage bills may leave little budget for investing in tools that could streamline operations or enhance service quality. Limited investment in productivity-enhancing technology, such as automation or digital solutions, can create a cycle where businesses struggle to keep up with larger competitors who are better positioned to capitalize on these advancements. Over time, this can diminish SMEs’ competitiveness, reducing their ability to attract and retain both customers and skilled employees.

Need for Government and Private Sector Collaboration

According to Foster, the business community’s shared goal with the government should be to find a solution to the inactivity and high labour costs affecting SMEs’ competitiveness. Collaborating to create incentives or subsidies that help SMEs invest in productivity-boosting tools, training, and digital transformation could be one way to bridge this gap. However, without targeted government intervention in this area, SMEs may continue to fall behind, limiting their contribution to the UK’s overall economic recovery.

6. Outlook for SMEs Amid Budget Uncertainty

The 2024 budget, while aimed at fostering equitable growth, presents a series of potential challenges for SMEs. Rising wages, declining retail sales, high business rates, and limited investment in productivity-enhancing technologies form a complex landscape for small businesses. For SMEs to thrive, many stakeholders argue that the government should consider policies that balance wage growth with support for productivity and ease of doing business.

Supporting SMEs for a Resilient Economy

Ultimately, SMEs play a vital role in the UK economy, contributing significantly to employment, innovation, and local communities. However, to adapt to the demands of wage increases, sluggish retail conditions, and structural cost burdens, SMEs will require careful management of costs and efficient planning. Government support through long-term business rate reform, targeted financial relief, and initiatives that facilitate investment in productivity could be instrumental in helping SMEs navigate these turbulent times.

As the effects of the budget unfold, SMEs across the UK will be watching closely, hoping for policies that not only support immediate challenges but also provide a foundation for sustainable growth in the years to come.